Breaking

Latest criminal justice updates and case developments

News

Plea Bargains

13 articles on plea bargains from Gavel Daily.

Plea BargainsOct 28, 2026

Does a Judge Have to Accept the Plea Deal You Negotiated?

A York County, S.C. judge turned down a negotiated 12-year plea in a felony DUI death case. Here's why judges can reject plea deals, the difference between binding deals and recommendations, and how to protect your right to withdraw a guilty plea.

Plea BargainsOct 28, 2026

Can Prosecutors Withdraw a Plea Deal After You Accept It?

The Supreme Court's refusal to revive the Guantanamo plea deals raises a question every defendant should ask: if you said yes to an offer, is it locked in? Usually not until you plead guilty. Here is how the rules work and what to get in writing.

Plea BargainsOct 19, 2026

Should You Take the First Plea Offer? Questions to Ask Before You Sign

The first plea offer often arrives before your defense has seen the full case. Supreme Court rulings and Federal Rule 11 explain why, and what to ask before you sign.

Plea BargainsOct 10, 2026

Can a Judge Sentence Below Guidelines After a Guilty Plea? A Fraud Case Where 46 Months Became 18

Prosecutors asked for at least 46 months. The judge imposed 18. A Manhattan federal fraud sentencing shows that a guilty plea settles guilt, not the sentence, and how mitigation shapes the final number.

Plea BargainsOct 5, 2026

Public Defender or Private Attorney for a Misdemeanor? How to Choose

Charged with a misdemeanor and unsure whether to take a public defender or hire your own lawyer? Here's when you have a right to free counsel, what "free" can cost, how caseloads affect your case, and how to decide.

Plea BargainsSep 16, 2026

Will Six Jurors Decide Your Felony Case?

The Supreme Court will decide in Kian v. Florida whether states can try serious felonies before juries smaller than 12, as Florida and Connecticut do with six jurors. Learn what a smaller jury changes at trial and what the pending case means for a plea decision you may be weighing now.

Plea BargainsSep 6, 2026

What Happens When Your Jury Cannot Agree?

A deadlocked jury ends your trial without ending your case. Here is how a judge gets to a mistrial, why a second trial is allowed, who decides whether it happens, and what the weeks before your status hearing are worth.

Plea BargainsAug 26, 2026

Oregon Dismissed 2,165 Cases Because Nobody Gave You a Lawyer. Then It Refiled 451 of Them.

Under State v. Roberts, Oregon must dismiss charges when an eligible defendant goes 60 days (misdemeanor) or 90 days (felony) after arraignment without appointed counsel. But the dismissal is without prejudice, and 451 of 2,165 dismissed cases have already come back. Here is what that actually means for someone waiting on a public defender.

Plea BargainsAug 21, 2026

Two Circuits Have Now Used the Supreme Court's New Appeal-Waiver Escape Hatch. Both Dismissed the Appeal Anyway.

In Hunter v. United States, the Supreme Court ruled 8-1 that a federal appeal waiver cannot be enforced when doing so would produce a miscarriage of justice. Two federal appeals courts have now applied that rule. Both dismissed the appeal in front of them. The Second Circuit's decision in United States v. Matos widened the doctrine and narrowed the practice in the same opinion.

Plea BargainsAug 16, 2026

Waive Your Jury in Louisiana and the DA Can Take Your Judge: HB 310 Took Effect August 1

Louisiana Act 541 took effect August 1, 2026. In districts with three or more criminal judges, filing to waive a jury now triggers automatic random reassignment of your case, and only the district attorney can stop it. A buried paragraph also restarts the speedy trial clock.

Plea BargainsJul 21, 2026

The Fine Print That Waives Your Appeal Can Now Be Torn Up: In Hunter v. United States the Supreme Court Says a Plea Deal Can't Lock In a 'Miscarriage of Justice'

On June 18, 2026, the Supreme Court ruled 8-1 that a federal plea deal's appeal waiver cannot be enforced when doing so would leave an egregious, system-discrediting error in place. Here is what the miscarriage-of-justice standard covers, what it still bars, and what it means for anyone who signed away their right to appeal.

Plea BargainsJun 23, 2026

Hunter v. United States Just Punched a Hole in Every Plea-Deal Appeal Waiver: The New 'Miscarriage of Justice' Exception Explained

On June 18, 2026, the Supreme Court ruled 8-1 that a federal appeal waiver cannot be enforced when doing so would leave in place an egregious error that brings the justice system into disrepute. Here is what Hunter v. United States changes for anyone weighing a plea deal.

Plea BargainsMay 26, 2026

When the Plea Deal Triggers Deportation: How Noncitizen Defendants Are Pulling Guilty Pleas Under Padilla in 2026

A 2025-2026 enforcement surge is sending noncitizen defendants back to court to vacate old guilty pleas under Padilla v. Kentucky. Here is how the doctrine works, which procedural vehicles are winning, and what the Supreme Court's Blanche v. Lau ruling could change.

All news