Breaking

Latest criminal justice updates and case developments

White Collar Crime

After a Hung Jury, a Motion for Judgment of Acquittal Ended the Ethereum Bot Fraud Case

A Manhattan federal judge acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers on all three counts a year after their jury deadlocked. This piece covers how a Rule 29 motion works, its 14-day deadline, and why the government can't appeal or retry.

Share
Illustrated empty courtroom viewed from a low angle, with a vacant jury box whose chairs are pushed back, rows of dark wood benches leading to the judge's bench, and a pen on a blank pad in the foreground, lit by a single beam of light.

A motion for judgment of acquittal asks the judge to rule that the prosecution's evidence is legally insufficient to convict. In federal court, Rule 29 lets a defendant make it after the government rests, after all the evidence, or within 14 days after a guilty verdict or after the jury is discharged, whichever is later.

On Monday, November 16, 2026, U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke in Manhattan granted that motion for Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, the MIT-educated brothers prosecutors accused of taking about $25 million in cryptocurrency from Ethereum trading bots in roughly 12 seconds. She acquitted them on all three counts (wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering), according to Law Commentary and Decrypt. Their jury had deadlocked a year earlier. A second jury never heard the case. The judge's ruling ended it.

That sequence matters to anyone whose trial ends without a verdict. A hung jury usually leaves the government free to try the case again. A judge's acquittal after a hung jury closes that door, and the government can't appeal it either.

The case timeline, from charges to acquittal

  • May 15, 2024: charges announced. The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York announced that Anton had been arrested in Boston and James in New York, according to the Justice Department release republished by the IRS. Each faced conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, and each count carried a maximum of 20 years in prison. The release said they obtained "approximately $25 million worth of cryptocurrency within approximately 12 seconds." The Block reported that Anton was 24 and James was 28, and quoted then-U.S. Attorney Damian Williams: "This alleged scheme was novel and has never before been charged."

  • October 2025: trial. The trial began in October 2025 and lasted nearly four weeks, Law Commentary reported.

  • November 7, 2025: mistrial. Clarke declared a mistrial after jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict.

  • November 16, 2026: acquittal. Clarke granted the brothers' motion for a judgment of acquittal on all three counts. Cointelegraph and Gizmodo also reported the Monday ruling.

The government's theory, as Decrypt describes it, was that the brothers placed bait transactions to lure specific "sandwich" trading bots, then "exploited a bug in a relay's code to see the bots' bundled trades before committing to a block." They swapped the bait for sell trades, and the bots lost about $25 million in roughly 12 seconds. Decrypt notes the government itself called the case "first of its kind" in its indictment.

The standard Judge Clarke applied

A judge deciding a Rule 29 motion doesn't ask whether she would have convicted. The Supreme Court set the test in Jackson v. Virginia (1979): "the relevant question is whether, after viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the prosecution, any rational trier of fact could have found the essential elements of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt."

That test tilts every doubt toward the government and still asks whether each element was proven. Clarke framed it the same way. As quoted by Gizmodo, citing Reuters, she wrote: "The question before the court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos' conduct was right or moral." She continued: "It is simply whether the evidence at trial, construed in a light most favorable to the government..."

She also wrote that the prosecution's arguments "disregard evidence about the Ethereum ecosystem, the technical meaning of a commitment," according to Gizmodo. A judge can find conduct troubling and still rule that the evidence doesn't prove the crime charged. That's the job Rule 29 assigns.

Why the government can't appeal or retry

The controlling case is United States v. Martin Linen Supply Co. (1977). The jury in that criminal contempt trial in the Western District of Texas was "hopelessly deadlocked" and was discharged. The trial judge then entered acquittals under Rule 29(c). The Supreme Court held that "the Double Jeopardy Clause bars appeal from an acquittal entered under Rule 29(c) after a jury mistrial," no less than an acquittal under Rule 29(a) or (b).

Martin Linen also explains what counts as an acquittal. Courts ask "whether the ruling of the judge, whatever its label," actually resolves, correctly or not, some or all of the factual elements of the offense charged. A ruling that the government failed to prove a required element, which is what Clarke found, fits that description.

The Advisory Committee's 1994 Note to Rule 29 states the rule plainly: "Under the double jeopardy clause the government may appeal the granting of a motion for judgment of acquittal only if there would be no necessity for another trial, i.e., only where the jury has returned a verdict of guilty." In the Peraire-Bueno case, the jury returned no verdict. With no guilty verdict to reinstate, there is nothing for the government to appeal and no second trial to hold.

How the outcomes compare

What happenedCan the government appeal?What the rules say
Judge acquits after a jury returns a guilty verdictYesThe 1994 Committee Note allows an appeal because reversal would simply reinstate the verdict. Under Rule 29(d), the judge must also conditionally decide any motion for a new trial in case the acquittal is later vacated or reversed.
Judge acquits after a hung jury (the Peraire-Bueno path)NoMartin Linen: double jeopardy bars an appeal from a Rule 29(c) acquittal entered after a jury mistrial. The acquittal is final.
Judge acquits before the case goes to the juryNoNo guilty verdict exists, so under the 1994 Note another trial would be needed. Martin Linen treats Rule 29(a) acquittals the same way.
Mistrial with no acquittalNot applicableA mistrial isn't an acquittal. The government can generally try the case again.

The timing rules defendants should know

The 14-day clock. Under Rule 29(c)(1), "A defendant may move for a judgment of acquittal, or renew such a motion, within 14 days after a guilty verdict or after the court discharges the jury, whichever is later." After a hung jury, the clock starts when the jury is discharged. Before 2009 the window was shorter. The 2009 Committee Note says the former rules "adopted 7-day periods" and that the period "has been expanded to 14 days."

Illustrated overhead view of a dark wood consultation table with two coffee cups, a blank legal pad with a pen, and a calendar page marked by a row of faint pencil ticks, lit by soft window light.

No earlier motion required. Rule 29(c)(3) says a defendant "is not required to move for a judgment of acquittal before the court submits the case to the jury as a prerequisite for making such a motion after jury discharge." If your lawyer didn't raise it during trial, the post-discharge motion is still available.

Reserving decision locks the record. Under Rule 29(b), the judge can hold off ruling, send the case to the jury, and decide the motion later, either after a guilty verdict or after the jury "is discharged without having returned a verdict." If the judge reserves, the decision must rest "on the basis of the evidence at the time the ruling was reserved." Evidence that came in afterward, including anything the defense put on, doesn't count against the defendant. The 1994 Note adds that the government's right to appeal "is only preserved where the ruling is reserved until after the verdict," which is why judges sometimes wait.

Putting on a defense after a denial. If the judge denies the motion when the government rests, Rule 29(a) says "the defendant may offer evidence without having reserved the right to do so."

What a Rule 29 motion is

Rule 29(a) is mandatory once the evidence falls short: "After the government closes its evidence or after the close of all the evidence, the court on the defendant's motion must enter a judgment of acquittal of any offense for which the evidence is insufficient to sustain a conviction." The judge can also raise it without a motion. It's a challenge to the legal sufficiency of the evidence, not a request for the judge to reweigh it, and the Jackson standard above governs.

Illustrated close-up of a law library shelf with gold-spined volumes in soft focus and one volume pulled slightly forward with a paper bookmark, lit by warm lamplight.

What the government had to prove, and where it fell short

Wire fraud requires a material misrepresentation. Law Commentary, Cointelegraph and Decrypt all report that Clarke found the government didn't prove one. According to Law Commentary, she found the bait transactions "contained no promise about how the brothers would execute their trades."

Decrypt reports that Clarke described Ethereum as a "trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use," and said the scheme "may have frustrated the spirit" of MEV-Boost, which isn't the same as fraud. The money laundering conspiracy count "relied on the proceeds of the alleged wire fraud," Decrypt reported, so it fell with the fraud counts.

If your jury hangs

A mistrial feels like a pause, but the 14 days after the jury is discharged can decide whether there's a second trial at all. Your lawyer can file or renew a motion for judgment of acquittal in that window even if no motion was made at trial. If the judge grants it on sufficiency grounds, Martin Linen makes that result final.

Rule 29 is a federal rule. State courts have their own versions, with their own deadlines and procedures, so the timing in a state case may differ. Ask your lawyer about the deadline in your court the day the jury is discharged, not weeks later.

The question Clarke left open

In a footnote, Clarke wrote that the prosecution "raises serious due process concerns," Decrypt reports, but she didn't rule on that question. She didn't need to. The case ended on the narrower ground that the evidence didn't prove a material misrepresentation, and she said in the ruling that she wasn't deciding whether the brothers' conduct was right or moral.

Sources

Note: This article contains AI-assisted content and has been reviewed by our editorial team.

IMPORTANT NOTICE: GavelDaily.com is an advertising and information service, not a law firm. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. The information you provide will be shared with licensed criminal defense attorneys in your area who may contact you about your inquiry. All submissions are treated as confidential by our service, but attorney-client privilege does not attach until you formally retain an attorney. Any attorney you connect with through this service is independently responsible for their legal advice and representation. Free consultations are subject to individual attorney availability. If you are facing an immediate legal emergency, contact your local public defender's office or call 911.

Frequently asked questions

What is a motion for judgment of acquittal?

It asks the judge to rule that the prosecution's evidence is legally insufficient to support a conviction. Under federal Rule 29(a), if the evidence is insufficient, the court must enter a judgment of acquittal.

What is the deadline for a Rule 29 motion after a hung jury?

Under Rule 29(c)(1), a defendant may move within 14 days after a guilty verdict or after the court discharges the jury, whichever is later. The period was 7 days before a 2009 amendment.

Can the government appeal a judge's acquittal after a mistrial?

No. In United States v. Martin Linen Supply Co. (1977), the Supreme Court held that the Double Jeopardy Clause bars an appeal from a Rule 29(c) acquittal entered after a jury mistrial.

When can the government appeal a judgment of acquittal?

According to the 1994 Advisory Committee Note to Rule 29, only when the jury has returned a guilty verdict, because reversing the acquittal would reinstate that verdict without a new trial.

Do I need to have made the motion during trial to file it after the jury is discharged?

No. Rule 29(c)(3) says a defendant is not required to move for acquittal before the case goes to the jury in order to make the motion after the jury is discharged.

Share

Reporting Note

Gavel Daily is an AI-operated publication. Articles may summarize statutes, court filings, or public reporting, but readers should verify time-sensitive legal details with primary sources or a licensed attorney.