Breaking

Latest criminal justice updates and case developments

Federal Crimes

If the Bureau of Prisons Miscounts Your First Step Act Credits, Where Do You Turn?

The Supreme Court heard Maxwell v. Dinis on Nov. 2, 2026. The case asks whether federal prisoners can use habeas to challenge how BOP applies First Step Act time credits to halfway-house and home-confinement transfers. This guide covers how credits work, the BOP grievance deadlines that come first, and what each possible ruling would mean.

Share
A closed manila folder, a spiral notebook with blurred handwritten lines and a pen rest on a car's passenger seat at dusk, with a wet road shining in the background.

Families of federal prisoners usually find out the math is wrong the hard way. The person inside has been working, taking programs and staying out of trouble, but the date for moving to a halfway house or home confinement keeps slipping. If the Bureau of Prisons (BOP) has miscounted, who can fix it? On Nov. 2, 2026, the Supreme Court heard argument in a First Step Act credits habeas case that could answer part of that question.

The case is Maxwell v. Dinis, No. 25-5930. No decision has come down yet. Until one does, a prisoner with a credit dispute should do what they'd have to do anyway: use BOP's grievance system on time and keep a paper trail, then talk to a lawyer about a habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2241.

What is Maxwell v. Dinis about?

It asks whether a federal prisoner can use habeas corpus to challenge how BOP applies First Step Act (FSA) time credits when what the prisoner wants is an earlier move to a halfway house or home confinement. The Fifth Circuit said no.

William Maxwell is serving a 20-year federal sentence. According to SCOTUSblog's preview, he's a former attorney who was convicted at trial of conspiring with organized-crime figures to take over and drain FirstPlus Financial Group, a Texas mortgage-loan company. He had no prison infractions and was moved to a low-security facility. Cornell's Legal Information Institute reports that he holds the lowest recidivism and violence risk ratings, earned FSA credits working as a prison cook and law clerk, began seeking prerelease custody in 2020, and filed his habeas petition in the Eastern District of Texas in 2022.

Maxwell argues that BOP failed to count some of his activities and that he's owed 42 to 48 months of credit. A magistrate judge recommended dismissing his petition because he hadn't exhausted BOP's administrative remedies, and the district court agreed. The Fifth Circuit affirmed for a different reason. Under its precedent in Melot v. Bergami, habeas covers only claims that would entitle a prisoner to accelerated release, and a transfer to a halfway house or home confinement doesn't count.

The Court agreed to hear the case on June 1, 2026. The question presented reads:

"Whether a claim regarding application of time credits under the First Step Act of 2018 seeking accelerated transfer to a halfway house or home confinement, can be brought in a habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2241."

How do First Step Act time credits work?

Eligible prisoners earn 10 days of time credits for every 30 days of successful participation in evidence-based recidivism reduction programs or productive activities. Prisoners rated minimum or low risk whose risk hasn't gone up over two consecutive assessments earn 5 more days per 30. That's the rule in 18 U.S.C. § 3632(d)(4).

There are limits. Programs completed before the Act was enacted don't count, and neither does time in pre-sentence detention. Many offenses disqualify a prisoner from earning credits at all, and a prisoner under a final order of removal can't apply them.

How credits are used is covered by 18 U.S.C. § 3624(g). To be transferred, a prisoner needs credits equal to the rest of their term and has to show a reduced or sustained low recidivism risk. For prerelease custody specifically, the prisoner must be rated minimum or low risk on the last two reassessments, or the warden has to approve a petition. Prerelease custody comes in two forms:

  • Home confinement: 24-hour electronic monitoring, with limited exceptions such as work and medical care.

  • Residential reentry center: what most people call a halfway house.

Credits can also start supervised release early, but that part is capped at 12 months.

The difference between those two uses is what Maxwell's case turns on. Halfway-house and home-confinement time is still part of the prison sentence, and BOP still oversees it. Supervised release is handled by a probation officer and the district court. The Fifth Circuit treated a transfer within BOP custody as something other than release, which is why it said habeas wasn't available.

Can First Step Act credits be lost or restored?

Yes to both. The BOP's First Step Act FAQ says plainly: "An inmate may lose earned FTC if they engage in misconduct."

The statute adds protections. Under § 3632(e), BOP has to give written notice, can take away only credits earned before the violation, and must have a process for restoring them. According to the BOP FAQ, a prisoner can ask for restoration at a Program Review after clear conduct for two consecutive risk and needs assessments. If the request is denied, they can reapply six months later.

What should a prisoner do first if the credit count looks wrong?

File a grievance through BOP's Administrative Remedy Program, and file it on time. This step decided Maxwell's case at the district court level: his petition was dismissed because he hadn't exhausted these remedies. The magistrate judge found he never raised his FSA claims through BOP's three-level appeal process. Maxwell says BOP obstructed that route. At the Supreme Court, the government is still arguing that his failure to exhaust is a reason to throw out the case.

A ruled sheet of blurred dated entries with a pen across it and a calendar with pencil-circled days, lit by a brass desk lamp on a dark wood desk.

The process has four steps, with deadlines set by federal regulation:

  • Informal resolution with staff, and

  • A formal BP-9 request to the warden. Both are due within 20 calendar days of the event being challenged (28 CFR 542.14). A late filing can be excused for a "valid reason," but nobody should count on that.

  • A BP-10 appeal to the Regional Director, due within 20 calendar days of the date the warden signed the response (28 CFR 542.15).

  • A BP-11 appeal to the General Counsel, due within 30 calendar days of the date the Regional Director signed the response. The regulation says "Appeal to the General Counsel is the final administrative appeal."

BOP has deadlines too, under 28 CFR 542.18. The warden gets 20 calendar days to respond, the Regional Director 30 and the General Counsel 40. Each level can extend its deadline once with written notice: 20 days at the institution, 30 at the regional level and 20 at the Central Office. If no response comes in time, "the inmate may consider the absence of a response to be a denial at that level." In other words, BOP's silence doesn't freeze the process. The prisoner can treat it as a denial and move up to the next level.

What happened at the Supreme Court argument?

The justices heard three positions. Because the government wouldn't defend the Fifth Circuit's rule, the Court appointed a lawyer to argue for it.

Empty damp stone steps rise toward tall columns and a plain pediment of a courthouse under soft overcast light, with a brass door handle softly blurred in the foreground.

Maxwell, represented by Masha Godina Hansford of Davis Polk & Wardwell, argues that §§ 2241 and 2243 are broad. He points to Preiser v. Rodriguez, in which a state prisoner had to use habeas to challenge denied good-conduct credits, as a close analog. He also says he has no other remedy. A Bivens claim is sharply limited, § 1983 doesn't reach federal officials, and review under the Administrative Procedure Act is likely barred by 18 U.S.C. § 3625.

The government, argued by Assistant to the Solicitor General Kevin J. Barber, agrees that the alternatives to habeas aren't available and won't defend the Fifth Circuit's bright-line rule. It proposes allowing habeas when a prisoner's imprisonment is allegedly being unlawfully prolonged, which it calls narrower than Maxwell's "level of custody" test. It also says Maxwell didn't exhaust his remedies and that 18 U.S.C. § 3621(b), which bars review of "a designation of a place of imprisonment," defeats his claim.

Court-appointed amicus Brian W. Barnes of Cooper & Kirk defended the Fifth Circuit's judgment. He proposed allowing habeas in only three situations: when the claim implies physical detention must be shortened or ended, when the prisoner is entitled to earlier release on bail or parole, or when the sentencing court ordered the sentence served somewhere it had no jurisdiction to send him.

Amicus briefs supporting the case's review came from FAMM, the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers with the National Association of Federal Defenders, habeas scholars, Rep. Jamie Raskin, and Sens. Dick Durbin and Cory Booker, according to the docket.

The argument's most unusual moment came from the government. Law360 reported that Barber asked the Court to dismiss the case as improvidently granted, arguing it would soon be moot. He admitted the government hadn't raised mootness when the Court was deciding whether to take the case: "That was our bad." Justice Sotomayor said he was trying to "win on an argument that you failed to raise on cert." Justice Gorsuch said, "I haven't heard 'my bad' before at the podium. Good on you."

Hansford pushed back. "We're happy with a narrow ruling here," she said, and "There's just no reason for this court to have buyer's remorse on this case."

Several justices seemed to want a narrow ruling. SCOTUSblog's recap reported that Justice Jackson questioned "whether we really need to use this case to define every circumstance in which habeas is appropriate." Justice Kagan told Barnes that "parole looks an awful lot like what's going on here." Justice Kavanaugh asked whether the § 3621(b) question could be left for the lower court on remand, and Barber said the Court "absolutely could." SCOTUSblog's Richard Cooke concluded that the justices seemed unlikely to limit Preiser or reject the parole analogy, and reluctant to decide § 3621(b).

What would each possible ruling mean for prisoners?

The Court could go several ways. None of these is a prediction.

The Court holds habeas is available. Federal prisoners could challenge credit-based transfer denials in a § 2241 petition. They would still have to get through BOP's grievance process first, and a narrow ruling might leave questions like § 3621(b) for the lower courts.

The Court affirms the Fifth Circuit. Habeas would be closed for claims seeking an earlier halfway-house or home-confinement transfer. Both Maxwell and the government agree the other legal routes are limited, so a prisoner in that position could be left with few options in court.

The Court dismisses the case as moot or improvidently granted. There would be no national answer, and the Fifth Circuit's rule would stay in place in that circuit. Prisoners elsewhere would remain under whatever their own circuit's law says.

Why does mootness matter in this case?

Even under BOP's own calculation, the government says Maxwell becomes eligible for a halfway-house transfer on Jan. 22, 2027. Once he's moved, his claim may no longer present a live dispute. According to Law360, Barber told the Court that if it rules, it "would probably also want to issue your judgment forthwith" "so that the mootness doesn't occur during the rehearing period." Gorsuch asked, "So, even if it's not moot here, it's going to be moot down there [in the lower court] real quick, is what you're telling us?" Barber answered, "Absolutely, yes."

That timing creates real pressure. If the Court doesn't decide before Maxwell's transfer, it may end up deciding nothing at all.

What families can do now

  • Keep records of programming. Write down program names, work assignments and dates. Maxwell's dispute is about activities he says BOP didn't count.

  • File within 20 days. The informal resolution and BP-9 deadline is short. File early rather than wait to see whether the numbers get corrected.

  • Track BOP's response deadlines. If a level doesn't answer in time, treat it as a denial and appeal to the next level within that level's deadline.

  • Talk to counsel or a federal defender about § 2241. Whether a habeas petition is an option may depend on the circuit and on how the Supreme Court rules in Maxwell.

Sources

Note: This article contains AI-assisted content and has been reviewed by our editorial team.

IMPORTANT NOTICE: GavelDaily.com is an advertising and information service, not a law firm. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. The information you provide will be shared with licensed criminal defense attorneys in your area who may contact you about your inquiry. All submissions are treated as confidential by our service, but attorney-client privilege does not attach until you formally retain an attorney. Any attorney you connect with through this service is independently responsible for their legal advice and representation. Free consultations are subject to individual attorney availability. If you are facing an immediate legal emergency, contact your local public defender's office or call 911.

Frequently asked questions

Can a federal prisoner file habeas over First Step Act credits?

The Supreme Court is deciding that in Maxwell v. Dinis, argued Nov. 2, 2026. The Fifth Circuit holds that habeas under 28 U.S.C. § 2241 covers only claims seeking accelerated release, not an earlier halfway-house or home-confinement transfer, and no Supreme Court decision has issued yet.

How many First Step Act credits can a prisoner earn?

Eligible prisoners earn 10 days of time credits for every 30 days of successful participation in recidivism reduction programs or productive activities. Prisoners rated minimum or low risk whose risk hasn't increased over two consecutive assessments earn 5 more days per 30.

What are the deadlines for a BOP grievance?

Informal resolution and the BP-9 request to the warden are due within 20 calendar days of the event. The BP-10 appeal to the Regional Director is due within 20 days of the warden's signed response, and the BP-11 appeal to the General Counsel is due within 30 days of the Regional Director's signed response.

What if BOP doesn't respond to a grievance?

Under 28 CFR 542.18, if a response doesn't arrive within the deadline, including any extension, the prisoner may treat the lack of a response as a denial at that level. That lets the prisoner move on to the next appeal.

Can lost First Step Act credits be restored?

Yes. BOP's FAQ says a prisoner can request restoration at a Program Review after clear conduct for two consecutive risk and needs assessments, and can reapply six months after a denial.

Share

Reporting Note

Gavel Daily is an AI-operated publication. Articles may summarize statutes, court filings, or public reporting, but readers should verify time-sensitive legal details with primary sources or a licensed attorney.