On Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2026, a Natrona County District Court jury in Casper, Wyoming found Grant Phillip Bauer, 35, not guilty of strangulation of a household member and domestic battery. The verdict came after a two-day trial and about 80 minutes of deliberation, Oil City News reported. Both people left the night in question with injuries: she had a fracture on the bridge of her nose and bruising on her neck, and he had a bitten finger and wrist pain. The case is a clear example of a self defense domestic violence charge going to a jury, and of how the burden of proof shapes the outcome.
If you or someone you know has been charged after a fight where both partners were hurt, the questions below walk through how self-defense works in Wyoming, what evidence usually decides these cases, and what happens after a not-guilty verdict.
What happened in the Casper case?
Casper police responded to a woman's call on Dec. 26, 2025. She said her boyfriend, Bauer, struck and choked her during an argument "about four or five times" and that she stopped him by biting his finger, according to Oil City News.

Bauer gave a different account. At the hospital, then-Casper police officer Jace Carver recorded him on body camera saying the woman "freaked out" and began punching him after an interaction involving her child. He said he pushed her face away, she bit his finger, and the two went to the ground while she was still biting it. Asked whether he struck her, he said: "I probably did. I slapped her in the face trying to get her off me." He denied choking her.
The State's evidence included testimony from the woman's mother that her daughter was covered in blood when picked up from Bauer's apartment, blood in the child's bedroom where the altercation happened, a photographed bruise on the woman's nose, and an emergency physician who testified that a CT scan showed a nasal fracture and "some bruising" on her neck.
Defense attorney Steven Iberlin told jurors to weigh the conflicts between the two accounts and the possible sequence of events that left both people injured. He argued the prosecution had to prove Bauer had not acted in self-defense after his finger was bitten. Prosecutor Amanda Kirby pointed to the medical testimony and to Bauer first telling officers that the blood and scratches on his face came from "shaving." She called his injuries consistent with defensive wounds and said differences between the woman's trial testimony and her first statements could be explained by trauma and chaos. "She told you what happened to her," Kirby said.
Can you claim self-defense if the other person was hurt worse?
Yes. Who was hurt worse does not decide a self-defense claim on its own. The question is whether the force used was what a reasonable person would judge necessary, and no more.
Wyoming's self-defense statute, W.S. 6-2-602(a), defines reasonable defensive force as the force "a reasonable person in like circumstances would judge necessary to prevent an injury or loss, and no more." Deadly force is covered only when necessary to prevent imminent death or serious bodily injury.
That framing explains why the Casper defense focused on sequence. Injuries on both sides show that force was used. They do not, by themselves, show who used it first or whether a given blow was a reasonable response. A slap meant to break a bite hold and a series of blows during an argument can produce similar medical records. Jurors are asked to reconstruct the order of events.
Does it matter who started it?
Yes. Wyoming's no-duty-to-retreat protection applies only to someone who is not the initial aggressor.
Under W.S. 6-2-602(e), a person attacked where they are lawfully present has no duty to retreat before using reasonable defensive force, provided they are "not the initial aggressor" and not engaged in illegal activity.
In Casper, the two accounts pointed in opposite directions on this point. The woman described being struck and choked repeatedly before she bit him. Bauer described being punched first and then bitten after pushing her face away. When accounts conflict this sharply, the question of who started the physical fight often becomes the center of the trial.
Who has to prove self-defense in Wyoming?
Once self-defense is properly raised at trial, the State must prove the absence of self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt, and the jury should be told so specifically.
That rule comes from the Wyoming Supreme Court's decision in Duckett v. State (Sept. 4, 1998). The court held that "when self-defense is properly raised the jury should be specifically instructed that the state has the burden to prove absence of self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt." It reversed an aggravated assault conviction where that instruction had been refused and held the rule is not limited to homicide cases.
This is the burden Iberlin built his closing around. The defense does not have to prove self-defense happened. Once the issue is in the case, the State has to disprove it to the same standard it must meet on every element of the charge.
Can a domestic violence case be dismissed before trial on self-defense grounds?
Possibly. Wyoming law provides pretrial immunity from prosecution for reasonable defensive force, and the defense can raise it by motion.

W.S. 6-2-602(f) says a person who uses reasonable defensive force "shall not be criminally prosecuted for that use of reasonable defensive force." In Manders v. State (June 3, 2026), the Wyoming Supreme Court set out how that motion works. The defendant must first make a "prima facie showing" that the statute applies. Then "the burden shifts to the State to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that § 6-2-602(f) does not apply." In Manders itself, the court affirmed the denial of the motion to dismiss.
Two different burdens are at work here. Before trial, on an immunity motion, the State's burden is a preponderance of the evidence. At trial, under Duckett, it is beyond a reasonable doubt. Losing an immunity motion does not take self-defense off the table for trial.
What do strangulation and domestic battery charges carry in Wyoming?
Strangulation of a household member (W.S. 6-2-509) covers intentionally and knowingly or recklessly causing or attempting to cause bodily injury to a household member by impeding normal breathing or blood circulation, through pressure on the throat or neck or by blocking the nose and mouth. It is a felony punishable by up to 10 years in prison.
Domestic battery (W.S. 6-2-511) means a household member knowingly or recklessly causing bodily injury to another household member by physical force. Penalties step up with prior convictions:
-
First offense: up to 6 months in jail, a fine up to $750, or both.
-
Second offense within 5 years: up to 1 year, a fine up to $1,000, or both.
-
Third or later offense within 10 years: up to 10 years, a fine up to $10,000, or both.
Wyoming also allows officers to make warrantless domestic-violence arrests on probable cause within 24 hours, even when the officer did not see the incident, under W.S. 7-20-102. That is one reason both partners in a mutual fight can find themselves under investigation quickly.
How are body-camera statements used at trial?
Your own words can be used against you. Under the rules of evidence, a party's own statement offered against them is not hearsay.
Federal Rule of Evidence 801(d)(2)(A) treats a statement offered against a party that "was made by the party in an individual or representative capacity" as not hearsay. That is why a defendant's body-camera explanations get played or described at trial.
The Casper case shows how this cuts both ways. Bauer's account at the hospital gave the defense its sequence-of-events theory: he was bitten, he pushed her face away, he slapped her "trying to get her off me." The prosecution used a different statement, his first explanation that the blood and scratches on his face came from "shaving," to argue his story had shifted. The practical lesson for anyone in this situation: what you say at the scene, at the hospital, or on the drive to the station can all become trial evidence.
What if the accuser does not testify?
In the Casper trial the woman did testify. When an accuser does not, the Sixth Amendment's Confrontation Clause can limit what her earlier statements to police may be used for.
The U.S. Supreme Court drew the line in Davis v. Washington (June 19, 2006). Statements to police are nontestimonial when their primary purpose is "to enable police assistance to meet an ongoing emergency." They are testimonial when the primary purpose is "to establish or prove past events potentially relevant to later criminal prosecution." The 911 call in Davis was admissible. In the companion case, Hammon v. Indiana, a battery affidavit taken on a domestic call was testimonial and should have been excluded.
Other hearsay routes can still apply. Federal Rule of Evidence 803 excepts an excited utterance, "A statement relating to a startling event or condition, made while the declarant was under the stress of excitement that it caused," and statements made for and reasonably pertinent to medical diagnosis or treatment that describe symptoms or their general cause. These are federal rules; state courts apply their own evidence rules, so the exact wording in a Wyoming courtroom is a question for your attorney.
How does medical evidence factor in?
Medical testimony often carries heavy weight in strangulation cases. A clinical article in American Nurse (McCarthy and Stagg, Feb. 5, 2020), citing Zilkens and colleagues, reports that "approximately 50% of strangulation victims will have no visible injuries." When a CT scan or a physician documents findings, as happened in Casper with the nasal fracture and neck bruising, that evidence becomes central.
The defendant's own medical records matter too. Bauer was treated for wrist pain and a finger bite. The defense used those injuries to support a sequence in which he was attacked first. The prosecution described the same injuries as defensive wounds. The records were the same; the dispute was over what they meant. If you were injured, documented treatment is evidence your attorney can work with.
What happens after an acquittal in Wyoming?
A not-guilty verdict does not erase the arrest record automatically, but Wyoming lets you petition to expunge it.
According to the Collateral Consequences Resource Center's summary of W.S. 7-13-1401, a person may petition to expunge arrest records "180 days after a non-conviction disposition" if no charges are pending. "A hearing is held only if the prosecutor objects."
The takeaway if you have just been charged
Injuries on both sides do not end a self-defense claim. In Wyoming, the defense raises self-defense, and the State must then disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt at trial. Pretrial immunity under 6-2-602(f) is a separate motion with its own lower burden on the State. And in most of these cases, the evidence that decides the outcome is the evidence created in the first hours: what each person told police, what the body camera recorded, and what the ER documented. Talk to a defense attorney before you add anything to that record.
Related reading
-
Should You Take the First Plea Offer? Questions to Ask Before You Sign
-
Which Past Acts Can Oklahoma Prosecutors Now Show a Domestic Violence Jury?
-
How the Protective Order Hearing Process Works When You're the Respondent
Sources
-
Wyoming Statutes § 6-2-509, Strangulation of a household member (FindLaw)
-
Wyoming Statutes § 6-2-602, Use of force in self-defense; no duty to retreat (FindLaw)
-
Wyoming Statutes § 7-20-102, Arrests without warrant (FindLaw)
-
American Nurse: Strangulation, a silent but deadly form of intimate partner violence (Feb. 5, 2020)
Note: This article contains AI-assisted content and has been reviewed by our editorial team.
IMPORTANT NOTICE: GavelDaily.com is an advertising and information service, not a law firm. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. The information you provide will be shared with licensed criminal defense attorneys in your area who may contact you about your inquiry. All submissions are treated as confidential by our service, but attorney-client privilege does not attach until you formally retain an attorney. Any attorney you connect with through this service is independently responsible for their legal advice and representation. Free consultations are subject to individual attorney availability. If you are facing an immediate legal emergency, contact your local public defender's office or call 911.
